Over the hours that passed, Williams succumbed to both mental and physical distress. When police raided his two homes, they not only uncovered a neatly catalogued trove of women's underwear and videotapes of the slayings, but hundreds of digital photos of the cat in a variety of poses and backdrops. Smyth drove to the top of the laneway, got out of his car and saw a rock pile to his left. As you can see here, everything in this room is videotaped and audiotaped, Smyth said, drawing the colonels attention to three mounted cameras that were recording their meeting from different angles. Detective Sergeant Jim Van Allen, a criminal profiler with the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP), assessed the information on the Orleans break-ins and deduced that as the intruder continued to evade detection, he was becoming more aggressive. . I had sort of a stomach flu, he said. Williams unfolded his arms and leaned forward, his interest keenly focused on the photographs before him. . The detective, as though trying to land a big fish, continued to pace his efforts by offering his adversary some slack before tactfully reeling him in just a little bit more. Loran Chaptis attended a house on Concession 13, Snowdon Township, Haliburton County. Snook said this type of approach relies on having an officer build a rapport with the suspect and listen carefully to what is said. Colonel Russell Williams Interview and Interrogation was performed by Jim Smyth. "Not everybody can be a great interrogator.". "I've covered courts and policing, [but] I've never seen anything like this. Then he was asked about Comeau and the circumstances of his first murder. As for the the current stage production, he said it's meant to examine a national trauma in a "safe space in which we can discuss.". A much more formal letter of condolence had been sent to Mr. Comeau on official Office of the Wing Commander military stationery on December 1, 2009, written and signed in the capacity of Marie-Frances commanding officer. . Smyth has also taught forensic interviewing and forensic behavioural science at Toronto's Seneca College. In June 1997 he began working with the OPP, moving to the behavioural sciences section of the force in 2000. Wisely, Smyth was careful not to overreact to the horrors he heard. Cause you know this would have a very significant impact on the base if they thought you thought I did this.. Butts, E. (2016). Williams seemed friendly and very agreeable, despite a touch of arrogance. No, Williams said, still sitting with his arms folded in front. It is a priority for CBC to create products that are accessible to all in Canada including people with visual, hearing, motor and cognitive challenges. He broke into her house on Highway 37 near Belleville, Ontario, at about 1:00 a.m. on 29 January, and found Lloyd asleep. The Ontario Crown announced Monday it will not appeal the Sept. 26 decision of Mr. Justice Kenneth A. Langdon that Det.-Sgt. Photo by Northern News / KL Because this is getting out of control really fast, Russell. James J. Smith is a retired FBI Supervisory Special agent. I had a realty lawyer, Williams chuckled, but, no, I dont have a lawyer.. He captured it all on video. Story continues below Barry Manion leaves court in Kirkland Lake in 2008 after being arrest in he 1970 disappearance of 12-year-old Katherine Wilson. The most effective seems to have been his use of false evidence to convince Mr. Armishaw that he was guilty.. This article was published more than 12 years ago. The graphic details were disclosed as though he were describing scenes from a grisly movie. Williams was decorated for his years of exemplary service and for a tour of duty in the Middle East. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Well, you start by telling the truth, Smyth replied firmly. .. That's what you're going through right now," Smyth is seen telling McClintic. . Theres no issue about the fact that youre the one that caused these injuries to Jaydin, okay? Det.-Sgt. Both women were asleep when Williams broke in. Over the next 10 hours, Williams gave a detailed confession around Lloyd, but also Corporal Marie-Frances Comeau and at least two other cases initially.The Behavior Panel is a group made up of the world's top body language and behavior experts, Mark Bowden, Scott Rouse, Greg Hartley, and Chase Hughes. "You can lie to the suspect and say you have evidence. If you do not yet have a Torstar account, you can create one now (it is free), Copyright owned or licensed by Toronto Star Newspapers Limited. When he returned later that same evening, he drove straight back to Ottawa to help his wife with some unpacking, since he had the Monday off work. Yeah, the colonel mumbled, his eyes still locked onto the desk. And, like many decisions that military airmen must make, it had to be quick and certain. "I just watched as they peeled the layers away and started presenting evidence, and found it quite fascinating the way it sort of segued into a confession," Perry told CTV's Canada AM in a recent interview. Jessica was a beautiful, gentle young woman. We apologize, but this video has failed to load. Smyth did not know the area well, but as he passed a house at a particular angle to the road, across from a laneway, he got a sense he was in familiar territory. I know you wont be able to believe me, but it is true. I touched the bag because I didn't know if it was a piece of scrap.". However, witnesses reported seeing a silver-coloured SUV parked in a field near Lloyds house on the night of her disappearance. Williams looked up at him, shook his hand, and then passively cast his eyes to the floor. [6] Glenn Woods, former director of the RCMPs behavioral sciences unit, doubts the investigation would have cost this much, and suggested the figure was likely a guesstimate thrown out by Smyth. He then elaborated on the difference between and interview and an interrogation and the techniques used. Top OPP interrogator credited with McClintic, Williams confessions | CBC News Loaded. suburb of Orleans. So as I said before, any point today you feel the need to speak to a lawyer, you just let me know and we can take you to a room where you can do that in private, okay?[4]. . During the burglaries Williams took photographs of female undergarments spread out on a bed, and of himself wearing brassieres and panties. Smyth abruptly changed the topic again and began discussing swipe access cards that were used on the base. Exclusive sports coverage by Bruce Garrioch, Ken Warren and Tim Baines, in-depth crime and news from Gary Dimmock and city life coverage from arts writers Lynn Saxberg and Peter Hum. In 2003, Smyth completed the International Criminal Investigative Analysis Fellowship Understudy Program, resulting in . Cause its tough to undo the rumor mill once it gets started. Williams raped her and made her pose for photographs. More aptly described as an enclosed cubicle, the video room, as police call it, was probably not much bigger than the walk-in bedroom closet at the colonels Ottawa home. Sgt. . Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. ", Audience Relations, CBC P.O. Smyth said in the interrogation. Yeah, he muttered. The detectives words fought gallantly for the women who no longer had a voice. One can hardly hear those words without being put in mind of The Borg portrayed in Star Trek, The Next Generation, the judge wrote. He realized that there would be significant consequences for his actions, so his decision had to be a calculated and informed one. They knew that if they did not have the search warrants and were not prepared to execute them while he was undergoing questioning, their suspect would likely have walked from the roomand possibly destroyed any evidence before they had the opportunity to find it. Jim Munsterman, Alicia Lampert and Bill Holmes. . Interviews are conducted one-on-one, so there is no real or perceived ganging up to intimidate the suspect. Russell Williams Case | The Canadian Encyclopedia Provincial Court Judge Mike Dinkel excluded the confession, concluding she told Calgary police what they wanted to hear. How do you feel about what youve done?. They were settled with undisclosed financial payments in 2014. But now his sly charm and relentless pursuit of confessions have derailed a major prosecution. .. The detective told him that further efforts had been taken to identify the vehicle responsible for making the tracks, including collecting witness reports. "The non-verbals are ringing loud and clear on this one. Sgt. After extending the colonel the opportunity to admit to any extramarital relationships, Smyth became blunt. If you are a Home delivery print subscriber, unlimited online access is, Famed detective Jim Smyth's interrogation techniques derail murder case, Canada's largest public sector strike leaves thousands in immigration limbo, Adam Zivo: The CBC has a unique obligation to be neutral, which it is failing, 'Why haven't they noticed the poor service?' "I could see a portion of a garbage bag underneath the rocks," Smyth testified, taking several long pauses as he appeared to compose himself. I told you when I came in here that Ill treat you with respect, and Ive asked you to do the same for me, he said. Chris Nicholas told reporters in Belleville earlier this week. The off-duty colonel removed his bright yellow jacket, draped it over the back of the chair, and placed his black leather gloves on the desktop before sitting down. I have never been interviewed by the police, he said with a smug grin. to colleagues, clients or customers, or inquire about Williams listened to the officer intently, with furrowed brows and a tightly clenched jaw. Over the next two hours, Williams repeatedly raped Comeau, beating her viciously if she resisted. McClintic is already serving a life sentence after pleading guilty two years ago to first-degree murder. Doug Bradley. Everything about the interrogation is crafted down to specific details about how the officer acts and requires a lot of preparation in advance, Downs said. The detective broke the cold silence. Smyth talked briefly about the four crimes that had by now obviously been linked: the two sexual assaults in Tweed, the sex murder of Marie-France Comeau, and the suspicious disappearance of Jessica Lloyd. The fact that Smyth calls him "Russell" is significant, said Mendelson, because it puts the detective and Williams on an even playing field. And its not issues that point away from you; its issues that point at you, okay? Smyth placed some photos onto the desktop. Intrigued by the accuracy of his measurement, the detective asked him how he had recalled such a specific distance. Jim Smyth - IMDb . To Jane Doe, his first sexual assault victim, he wrote: I apologize for having traumatized you the way I did. . really fast.. ., Tire tracks are a major source of evidence for us.. The judge also said he did not believe the dishonest testimony of another detective-sergeant at the Guelph Police Service, who also exhibited laziness [and] indifference to the judicial process. . Insp. In fact, it wasnt even halfway over. is quickly expiring.. The sketch showed a laneway across from a house set at a particular angle to the road, court has seen. Neighbours at his former home in the Ottawa suburb of Orleans, as well as neighbours at the couple's cottage in the village of Tweed, recalled the decorated officer being near tears when he told them about Curio's passing. Smyth and another officer escorted him from the police building at 1:33 a.m. and arrived on the scene on the outskirts of Tweed at 3:47 a.m. Williams led them straight to her body, her head still wrapped in towels, exactly where he had told them it could be found: behind a large rock, forty feet from the road, and exactly 0.7 kilometers from the intersection of East Hungerford Road. The detectives relaxed posture and gentle hand gestures deceptively concealed the fact that he was about to drop a bomb on the colonels head. The detective explained how his computers would be forensically analyzed and that no stone would be left unturned. McClintic had also worked with a sketch artist to provide a composite sketch of the house. After thirty seconds of silence, the colonels head started to nod. He was subsequently kept under 24-hour watch. It was behind that rock pile and underneath an evergreen tree that police would find Tori Stafford, she said. However,Smyth and the OPP told CBC Toronto they are opposed to the production and Smyth fully supports the efforts of Lloyd's family and friends to stop it. He wrapped her body in a duvet and left it in her bedroom, where it lay undiscovered for more than 30 hours. . . Have you spent much time thinking about it?, Yeah, but I dont know the answers. Williams took a long pause, his eyes glazed. Smyth was not the only police officer to be criticized in the ruling. things like that?. Ed Johnson - Sergeant - Ontario Provincial Police | ZoomInfo ", Eventually, Williams reveals that he is concerned about the fact the OPP will soon be "tearing apart my wife's brand new house. Involved in countless murder and. 9 September 2007, Williams broke into a neighbours cottage while the family was away, and took photographs of himself in pornographic poses with a young girls underwear, some of which he stole. As a production about the murders of Jessica Lloyd and Cpl. This copy is for your personal non-commercial use only. 365 Bloor Street East, Toronto, Ontario, M4W 3L4. . ", "I just want people to know how hurtful this is, how harmful this has been. He used rational arguments to convince Williams that he had been caught. Yeah, no, I understand, Williams interrupted. "Its a science and an art," he said. He really didnt understand himself any better than the detective did. Thats a little microphone.. The video begins with. She set high standards for herself and others and was devoted to the well-being of those around her. . I am persuaded that Mr. Armishaws will was overcome. The detectives conversational-style questioning flip-flopped around with little apparent focus, often seeming to lack any specific direction or structure. He offered Williams another chance to explain how or why his DNA could have gotten inside any of the victims homes. Smyth then began focusing his questions on Marie-France Comeau, and asked Williams how they had met. On the night of 23 November 2009, in Brighton, a town just west of Trenton, Williams broke into the home of Corporal Marie-France Comeau, who was under his command at CFB Trenton. OJ Simpson returns to Las Vegas after release from prison after serving After several minutes of backpedaling, the detective managed to salvage the interview and refocus on the aspects that had been breaking the colonels resolve. I drove to Ottawa in the morning, he said as he sat up and folded his arms again. David A. Gibb, Camouflaged Killer (2011). The few people who were close with Col. Williams have said Curio's death, which took place around the 2008 Christmas holidays, had a profound and visible impact. 2023 Ottawa Sun, a division of Postmedia Network Inc. All rights reserved. "Its experience, it's aptitude," the former detective, who spent more than 20 years with the Toronto police, said. Undercover officers were posted to watch Wilkie Drive, but without results. "It's a smart man being outsmarted by a smarter man.". Some of the memory cards were simply stowed in a camera bag, while others were tucked away in a desk drawer in his office. "It's a smart man, outsmarted by a smarter man," OPP Det. Several hours pass by and Smyth makes it increasingly clear there is heavy suspicion surrounding Williams. Circumstances. With three simple, yet ominous, words, the distinguished base commander, respected colonel, and trusted pilot for the prime minister and Queen Elizabeth II had sealed his fate and was set to shock an entire nation. Smyth speaks in a friendly tone and tells Williams that he appreciates his co-operation in the matter. Jim Smyth, M.O.M. - Chief Instructor - Integrity Interviewing for Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay, Rex Murphy and others. Russ, maybe this would help. Williams looked insulted, then exhaled deeply, grinned wide, and shook his head. . Ontario Provincial Police - Ontario Police Memorial Foundation . Your vehicle drove up the side of Jessica Lloyds house. Williams had chosen to place her body off to the side of a rarely used, unpaved access road about six miles east of Tweed. Detective Inspector (formerly Detective Sergeant), "Top OPP interrogator credited with McClintic, Williams confessions | CBC News", "Famed detective Jim Smyth's interrogation techniques derail murder case", "Veteran detectives share stories of PTSD", "OPP officer tells of how he discovered Tori Stafford's body", "Christie Blatchford: A sketch and a hunch led Jim Smyth to find Tori Stafford's body", "James Smyth's Order of Merit of the Police Forces Citation", "Detectives in Russell Williams case honoured by Governor General", "James Smyth's Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medal Citation", "James Smyth's Police Exemplary Service Medal Citation", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jim_Smyth&oldid=1147621219, This page was last edited on 1 April 2023, at 03:35. . Super Bowl-winning athlete talks football, his medical career and the importance of skin care. But the problem is, Russell, every time I walk out of this room, theres another issue that comes up, okay? Canada ends evacuation flights from Sudan over 'deteriorating security situation', Royal Family unveils sneak peek of King Charles III and Queen Camillas coronation robes, Widening manhunt for Texas gunman slowed by 'zero leads', Tom Mulcair: Should Trudeau lead the Liberals against Poilievre? At some point during the evening, Colonel Russell Williams was formally arrested for the murders of Marie-France Comeau and Jessica Lloyd, as well as the two sexual assaults against Laurie Massicotte and Jane Doe. JOIN OUR BODY LANGUAGE MASTERCLASS: http://thebehaviorpanel.com/PLEASE SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/thebehaviorpanel?sub_confirmation=1 MERCH STORE: https://thebehaviorpanel.myspreadshop.com/FACEBOOK GROUP: https://www.facebook.com/groups/thebehaviorpanelists : Body Language Tactics - https://body-language-tactics.mykajabi.com/body-language-tactics-landing : FREE TRAINING: http://TruthAndLies.ca : http://BehaviorProfiler.com : Body Language Tactics https://body-language-tactics.mykajabi.com/body-language-tactics-landingTRUE CRIME PLAYLIST: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLguNzIxZa3ERwKVFvXw7ynFGH36PveAtYDetective-Sergeant Jim Smyth began his career with the York Regional Police (in Ontario, Canada) in 1988 before joining the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) in 1997.